Loading...
Considerations of variability and power for long-term monitoring of stream fish assemblages
Journal Title
Keywords
Readers/Advisors
Journal Title
Term and Year
Publication Date
2021-02
Book Title
Publication Volume
Publication Issue
Publication Begin
Publication End
Number of pages
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Journal Issue
Abstract
Little attention has been given to optimizing statistical power for monitoring stream fish assemblages. We explored the relationship between temporal variability and statistical power using 34 metrics from fish community data collected annually at six sites over 10 years via electrofishing. Metric variability differed by the life stage and group of species considered, use of abundance or mass data, and data standardization technique. Lower variability was associated with community data, abundance data, and time-based standardizations, while greater variability was associated with young-of- the-year data, mass data, and area-based standardizations. Simulation-based power analysis indicated metric choice, and to a lesser degree, monitoring design (annual, biennial, endpoints, or haphazard sampling) influenced power to detect change. Across a fixed number of surveys (N = 60), endpoints sampling performed best. The N needed to detect change was heavily dependent upon metric choice for all monitoring designs, with the most biologically specific metrics requiring greater N. Large savings in effort and resource expenditure can be obtained utilizing biologically relevant metrics that are robust to temporal noise within an appropriate sampling design.
Citation
Scott D. George, Daniel S. Stich, and Barry P. Baldigo. Considerations of variability and power for long-term monitoring of stream fish assemblages. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences. 78(3): 301-311. https://doi.org/10.1139/cjfas-2020-0013
Description
Accessibility Statement
Electronic Accessibility Statement: SUNY Oneonta is committed to providing equal access to college information by ensuring our digital content is accessible by everyone regardless of physical, sensory, or cognitive ability. This item has been checked by Adobe Acrobat Accessibility Check and remediated with the following result: [Remediation: title, language, autotagged and hand tagged // Hazards: tagged annotations, character encoding, alt text, table headers]. To request further accessibility remediation on this SOAR repository item for your specific needs, please contact openaccess@oneonta.edu.